InfoQ

News

Presentation: Architecture Evaluation in Practice

Posted by Floyd Marinescu on Oct 08, 2007 10:27 AM

Community
Architecture
Topics
Delivering Quality,
Enterprise Architecture
Tags
Architecture Evaluation,
JAOO Conference,
ThoughtWorks
Unverified designs, assumptions and tradeoffs increase the risks that software architecture doesn't meet expectations and costs significantly higher than projected. Ultimately they can cause projects to fail. This realization is prompting an increasing number of companies to consider assessing the quality of their software architectures. While architecture evaluation is not as widely used as it should be, some do try it. A few succeed, while others discover that they are not well prepared to do it. Many architecture evaluations are fixated on technology. While answering questions such as "Should the architecture use .NET or J2EE?" "Is the communication asynchronous or does it employ polling?" and "Does an XML versioning scheme exist?" can detect potential problems, there's more to architecture evaluation than technology alone.

In this presentation, recorded at JAOO 2006, Dragos Manolescu shares insights he gained from growing ThoughtWorks' architecture evaluation practice and evaluating several architectures for Global 1000 companies. These insights aim at preparing people interested in commissioning, managing, performing, participating in, or analyzing the results of architecture evaluation to tackle the realities of the front line.

Watch Architecture Evaluation in Practice (43 min)

Dragos Manolescu is a Software Architect in the Patterns and Practices group at Microsoft. He has been involved with software since before the days of curly braces and has worked at research institutes (CNET, IMEC, IMAG, NCSA), in product development, for professional services companies, and in academia. He co-authored Integration Patterns (Microsoft Press, 2004) and was the lead editor of Pattern Languages of Program Design, Volume 5 (Pearson Education, 2006). Prior to joining Microsoft he developed and led ThoughtWorks' Architecture Evaluation practice, assisting Global 1000 companies with the evaluation and design of software architectures. He holds a PhD in Computer Science from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. More information about his research and interests is available from micro-workflow.com.

3 comments

Reply

  1. Back to top

    download?

    Oct 12, 2007 5:08 AM by Tom McMillen

    Is there anyway to get a download of the presentation? I'd like to show this at work, but we can't access the streamed version?

  2. Back to top

    Re: download?

    Oct 16, 2007 11:51 PM by Allen Montejo

    i think infoq should have an download feature to their presentations

  3. Back to top

    Re: download?

    Jun 30, 2008 3:05 PM by berkay NiQuiL

Exclusive Content

Rationalizing the Presentation Tier

Thin client paradigm characterized by web applications is a kludge that needs to be repudiated. Old compromises are no longer needed and it's time to move the presentation tier to where it belongs.

Agile Project Management: Lessons Learned at Google

In this presentation filmed during QCon 2007, Jeff Sutherland, the creator of Scrum, talks about his visit at Google to do an analysis of Google's first implementation of Scrum.

AtomServer – The Power of Publishing for Data Distribution

In this article, Bryon Jacob and Chris Berry introduce AtomServer, their implementation of a full-fledged Atom Store based on Apache Abdera, which is now available as open source.

An Introduction to Virtualization

It is easy to think that virtualization applies only to servers. In reality the recent resurgence of the concept is also being applied to networking, storage, and application infrastructure.

REST Anti-Patterns

In this article, Stefan Tilkov explains some of the most common anti-patterns found in applications that claim to follow a "RESTful" design and suggests ways to avoid them.

Choosing between Routing and Orchestration in an ESB

In this article, Adrien Louis and Marc Dutoo discuss the differences and relative merits of using orchestration vs. routing in a typical ESB setup, and discuss various implementation options.

Enterprise Batch Processing with Spring

Wayne Lund discusses batch processing, Spring Batch objectives and features, scenarios for usage, Spring Batch architecture, scaling, example code, failures and retrying, and the future roadmap.

User Story Estimation Techniques

Developer Jay Fields draws on his experiences as a ThoughtWorks consultant to describe effective user story estimation techniques.