BT
x Your opinion matters! Please fill in the InfoQ Survey about your reading habits!

Agile Is a Culture Not a Process

by Amr Elssamadisy on Feb 26, 2009 |

Jeff Patton suggest that Agile is really a culture that generates process and not just a process and that should directly affect the way we teach others to Adopt Agile.  He introduces this idea with a lunch conversation:

Sitting with my friend Jonathan at lunch last week, we were talking about the process changes he felt like he was being cornered into making. He was adding more teams, and teams were growing. Things needed to change. Jonathan was justifiably concerned that all the new process being added would erode at the fluid communication and teamwork he’d worked so hard to promote. “How do you keep those things in your process?” He wondered. After talking a bit we decided that those things weren’t really process points – rather they were part of his company’s culture. These were the things he and others in his company valued.

Once in a while I feel particularly wise. It’s fleeting, and sometimes I get a “false positive” – stupid ideas that sound wise. But I said this, and it sounded wise enough to Jonathan.

Culture is process. Identify your culture and promote that.

Jeff goes on to suggest that culture actually generates process:

culture doesn't dictate a precise process, cultural values supported by teaching structures embedded in cultures and enforcement structures such as norms and mores all lead to a commonly understood process.

Jeff then discusses what it means for Agile to be a culture.  According to Jeff, the culture of Agile includes stories, heroes, myths, legends and jokes such as the C3 project (a legend in the XP world), Ward Cunningham and Big Dave Thomas (heroes), and the chicken and pig joke behind Scrum.  The culture of Agile involves values, norms, takeaways, and taboos such as the Agile Manifesto (values) and YAGNI and BDUF (taboos).  The culture of Agile is a world unto itself that those immersed in it for years pick up in bits and pieces along the way.

So what?  How should this affect how we help others enter the Agile world?

1. Underscore agile values that motivate practice I find it more necessary to highlight and underscore the values that motivate the process or technique I'm speaking about.

2. Identify organization values that compete with agile values When I sense concern from someone about a particular agile process point or practice, I work to identify the agile value the process supports and to identify what's valuable to the person with the concern. I'm looking for a conflict of values.

3. Be sensitive to culture shock I'm more sensitive to culture shock. The terminology, stories, and ritual that agile is chocked full of are bound to make anyone feel a bit uncomfortable. In particular, people who've spend a great number of years working in software development may be feeling something they haven't felt for many years – uncomfortable doing their own jobs. They may feel like someone has drugged them, put them on an airplane, and dropped them off on a foreign country without their consent. They may have incorrectly assumed they were just learning a new process.

We've always known that there was an Agile culture.  Jeff takes this a step further by suggesting that Agile IS a culture and the process and practices are generated from that culture.  Therefore we should teach culture first and foremost.

Hello stranger!

You need to Register an InfoQ account or or login to post comments. But there's so much more behind being registered.

Get the most out of the InfoQ experience.

Tell us what you think

Allowed html: a,b,br,blockquote,i,li,pre,u,ul,p

Email me replies to any of my messages in this thread

And if your culture is waterfall? by Francisco Jose Peredo Noguez

And what if the culture of the place where you currently works is waterfall? What to do then? A Cultural revolution? Or just run away? What if you need to feed you family, and believe it is going to be hard to find another job? And... what if you have switched jobs many times in the past, and have never landed in a company with an agile culture... what if companies with an agile culture are only a myth developers write about to give hope to each other...

Re: And if your culture is waterfall? by Juan Bernabo

What if you choose the next organization you are going to work better, and not leave it to the luck make you land on an agile organization?

Or what if you wait till someone cames to your organization and does the job of helping the organization see value in Agile?

Or better what if you are the one who does it?

I cannot force an organization to adopt Agile, it must prefer Agile, but to prefer it must value, but to value must understand what is in for them, what all will win, how they will stop loosing and why.

Does the organization have pains?
Does it realize that some of this pains are generated by this culture, values, beliefs, practices?
Does the organization pains are more painfull than the change pains?
Does this pains are at the business level too?

So for thouse organizations that don't have enough pain to move, and enough business reazons to change, probably is better to leave alone and look for an organization that is ready to transition.

Juan.

Finishing it I would say... by Rafal Ziolkowski

There are 10 types of people, those who understand binary system and those who not :) Also there are "clerks" and "problem solvers". Clerks like procedures and formal approach, problem solvers... You know they focus on tasks/problems and right way to fix it.

We learn differently by Amr Elssamadisy

The little I know of people and effective learning tells me that there is no one answer. Agile is a culture - sure. But I've seen people learn practices and have the values evolve as they see the practices go well.

I've seen existing cultures smother Agile as Fransisco laments. I've seen it the other way around, where a culture is dying and is replaced by an Agile culture. I've seen grassroots efforts succeed and fail. I've also seen Top Down initiatives succeed and fail.

The commonality (not necessarily the cause) I've found is that they all do so because Agile is better for them - personally and professionally. There have always been great people on those initiatives, but I don't know if they were there all the time or Agile brought something out in them....

So - yeah Agile is a culture - but so what? What works for one person, team, and organization doesn't necessarily work for the other.

Allowed html: a,b,br,blockquote,i,li,pre,u,ul,p

Email me replies to any of my messages in this thread

Allowed html: a,b,br,blockquote,i,li,pre,u,ul,p

Email me replies to any of my messages in this thread

4 Discuss

Educational Content

General Feedback
Bugs
Advertising
Editorial
InfoQ.com and all content copyright © 2006-2014 C4Media Inc. InfoQ.com hosted at Contegix, the best ISP we've ever worked with.
Privacy policy
BT