This is the Engineering Culture Podcast, from the people behind InfoQ.com and the QCon conferences.
In this podcast Shane Hastie, Lead Editor for Culture & Methods, spoke Lee Cunningham of VersionOne about the results from the State of Agile Survey.
Key Takeaways
- Agile is not just something that developers do – it’s an enabler of business outcomes
- The emergence of multi-modal organisations where there are multiple different approaches being used simultaneously, which holds them back from progressing effectively
- Some organisations are adopting a Taylorism approach to agile adoption – get experts to tell us what to do and control the teams to abide by those rules
- The emergence of business value as an important measure, over productivity (although productivity is a necessary precondition for business value)
- Buying an expensive tool doesn’t make your agile adoption successful, in the same way that buying an expensive treadmill doesn’t make you fit – both need to be used effectively to deliver any value
Subscribe on:
Show Notes
0:25 - Introductions
1:25 - This is the 11th Annual State of Agile survey
1:35 - The multi-year trend for larger organisations to embrace agility
1:50 - Agile is not just something that developers do – it’s an enabler of business outcomes
2:08 - Where Agile is in the adoption curve – there is still a long way to go. Less than 60% of organisations that respond to the survey have half or more of their teams using agile approaches
2:48 - 80% of respondents see themselves as not fully mature in their agile practices
3:35 - The emergence of multi-modal organisations where there are multiple different approaches being used simultaneously, which holds them back from progressing effectively
4:28 - Executive sponsorship is a vitally important ingredient for a successful agile transformation
4:54 - The difference between Lean and Taylorism – who makes the decisions about making changes to work practices; an “expert” or the person doing the work
5:23 - Some organisations are adopting a Taylorism approach to agile adoption – get experts to tell us what to do and control the teams to abide by those rules
5:38 - These organisations are missing the “inspect and adapt” aspect and not getting valuable results from their process changes
6:20 - The value of consistency of process and the usefulness of common tools
7:20 - The challenge of finding common ground where different areas of the organisation have adopted different approaches
7:45 - Scaled Agile Framework is now the most widely adopted framework for enterprise agile adoption in large organisations
8:35 - The emergence of business value as an important measure, over productivity (although productivity is a necessary precondition for business value)
9:20 - Evidence of the disconnect between what is important at the strategic level and the activities at the team level across organisations
10:03 - The groundswell of interest in DevOps as evidenced by the survey results
10:50 - DevOps must support the need to aggregate the work of multiple teams
11:10 - The differences between the reasons for adopting agile and the benefits achieved from that adoption
11:25 - Top three reasons for adopting:
- Accelerate product delivery
- Manage changing priorities
- Increase productivity
11:38 - The top three benefits actually achieved_
- Manage changing priorities
- Improved project visibility
- Increased team productivity
11:57 - The importance of knowing why the organisation is adopting agile
12:45 - The emergent nature of many of the benefits – things that were not expected
13:47 - The prevalence of Scrum as the primary framework for agile adoption
14:45 - The lines between the brands are now very blurred – practices from Scrum, Lean and XP are in use in most Scrum implementations
15:25 - Exploring the use of specific practices
16:48 - The difference between self-organisation, and picking the practices which seem easy that seem to fit with the organisations current constraints
17:43 - Not enough freedom and empowerment for teams to resolve problems themselves
18:17 - The relatively high proportion of teams not using the strong technical practices, such as unit testing
19:35 - The unsustainable pace of work (69% or respondents said they were not practicing a sustainable pace)
20:05 - Over 50% of organisations using agile in outsourced projects
21:15 - The proportion of respondents achieving success from using an agile approach
22:13 - The largest challenge to successful adoption is (still) the mismatch between company culture and agile values
22:43 - Buying an expensive tool doesn’t make your agile adoption successful, in the same way that buying an expensive treadmill doesn’t make you fit – both need to be used effectively to deliver any value
23:18 - Successful agile adoption needs to be a collective initiative with support from the very top of the organisation
23:40 - The organisations who are really getting value from agile at scale are often the ones who have failed previously – they are able to take those learnings and improve their adoption approaches
24:35 - The current trend for “digital” transformation is a manifestation of the desire by organisations to take a lean approach. Digital and Agile are both instances of lean thinking and have a lot in common
25:14 - The challenges to adoption are well known, and organisations which continue to experience these problems are not feeling the pain from the challenges, yet; they haven’t been disrupted, yet
25:40 - The story of an organisation where the culture was so command-and-control based that the only people remaining were the ones who needed to be told what to do
27:06 - Tackling the “don’t scale agile” objections
28:03 - What scaling means in this context – agile is successful at the team level and there is a desire to make it happen at the corporate level
28:33 - Things that are necessary for success at the team level and how they can be replicated at the larger organisation level (or not)
29:14 - The conundrums of scaling are related to the widely variant ways of working across the organisation
30:05 - SAFe has the largest adoption rate of the scaling models (28%)
30:48 - SAFe is based on some solid Lean and Lean Economics theories
31:25 - Scrum-of-Scrums is the second most prevalent and it works up to a certain size and complexity
32:02 - LeSS and DAD far lower takeup levels
32:36 - Top tips for success in scaling agile adoption
32:58 - The importance of training for successful scaled adoption
34:05 - The value that having an external coach or consultant brings to the conversations around successful adoption
34:35 - The importance of building internal coaching capacity for large scale adoption
35:35 - Trends around tool development – simplified UI and open architecture which supports integration
Mentioned:
Software Delivery Practices Evolve Fast, So Should Your Learning: Attend QCon San Francisco Software Development (Oct 24-28).
What are the major trends that matter right now in software development and technical leadership? Uncover emerging software trends and practices to solve your complex engineering challenges, without the product pitches. Save your spot now!,
Community comments